Worst case circuit stress analysis advanced energy. When designing a circuit in ltspice, you may wish to assess the impact of component tolerances. Improve logic timing with worstcase analysis electronic. Electronic circuit design and analysis for space applications. Worst case analysis is much more common than average case analysis because its often easier to get meaningful average case results, a reasonable probability model for typical inputs is critical, but may be unavailable, or dif. Worst case circuit analysis an overview e 1 e c t r o n i c p art s c i r cu i t s to 1 er an ce an a 1 y s i s walter m. The tolerance value should be given in your design requirement. Complete the following steps to configure and run a worst case analysis.
Worst case design of op amp circuits introduction building reliable hardware requires all component tolerances to be accounted for during the design stage. A dc, ac or transient worst case analysis can be performed only testing the circuit for the vertices of a polytope in conjunction with a circuit simulator or computational environment. This paper describes an approach adopted for a worst case circuit analysis done on an autonomous, passive, fail proof balancing electronic circuit. This process is accomplished by analyzing a circuit s variability with respect to part parameter tolerance extremes. Simulators like spice perform the worst case analysis in conjunction with a dc or ac.
Monte carlo analysis in excel a design tool for the component. In 2017, i was teaching a worst case circuit analysis wcca training course to engineers at an automotive company. Worst case analysis an overview sciencedirect topics. Lets say that we want to look at the worstcase impact of a r1 22. Pdf this paper describes an approach adopted for a worst case circuit analysis done on an autonomous, passive, fail proof balancing electronic circuit. C monte carlo defined by the probability distnbution of the variability no sensitivity analysis required. Worstcase circuit analysis wcca or wca is a costeffective means of screening a design to ensure with a high degree of confidence that potential defects and deficiencies are identified and eliminated prior to and during test, production, and delivery. Extreme value analysis each component is varied in the direction of the sensitivities to obtain the absolute worst case values of the circuit performance. Thefreedictionary the purpose of the short circuit study is to determine the fault current available at the various buses on your system. Participants learn the importance of this analysis and the different methods which can be utilized. This paper has been prepared utilizing material from design and evaluation, inc.
Worstcase circuit analysis wcca examines the effects. Shortcircuit current calculations cooper industries. This paper discusses using worst case circuit stress analysis. Frank halula provided the final update to the failure modes, effects and criticality analysis fmeca guidelines provided in appendix a. However, for a worst case analysis we would prefer not to use a distribution approach, instead the maximum deviation from the nominal value of each component are used in the calculations. Wccsa as a technique for ensuring the reliability of electronic circuits under most operating.
Worstcase circuit analysis with minimal simulations. Introduction to worst case circuit analysis for the aerospace engineer course overview. Worst case design ensures that hardware meets or exceeds the design specifications for the life of the product. Worst case analysis of linear analog circuit performance. Examine the worst case to guarantee that the dynamic discipline is not violated for any register many registers in a system.
In this example you will use worst case analysis to determine if the circuit will continue to oscillate under the worst conditions. Worst case analysis of linear analog circuit performance based on kharitonovs rectangle liuxi qian 1 dian zhou1, shengguo wang2, xuan, zeng3 1erik jonsson school of engineering and computer science, university of texas at dallas, dallas, tx 75080, usa 2college of engineering, university of north carolina at charlotte, charlotte, nc 282230001, usa. Design and analysis of electronic circuits for worst case environments and part variations c rootsumsquare defined by the biases and standard deviations of the parts variability and magnitude of circuit sensitivities. Hardness assurance methodology for analog single event. A short circuit is an abnormal condition of relatively low resistance between two points of differing potential in a circuit, usually resulting in a flow of excess current. Assume the worst case scenario of 64ka available fault current from bus feeding a small motor load of normal current below 50a. Worst case analysis, electronic partscircuit tolerance analysis, worst case scenario, worst case part. Worst case design techniques do not change the basic transfer equations for an op amp circuit. Component tolerances for common electronic components are studied in depth. Worst case circuit analysis wcca or wca is a costeffective means of screening a design to ensure with a high degree of confidence that potential defects and deficiencies are identified and eliminated prior to and during test, production, and delivery. Worst case circuit analysis wcca or wca is a cost effective means of screening a design to ensure with a high degree of confidence that potential defects and deficiencies are identified and eliminated prior to and during test, production, and delivery.
Which process corner tt, ff, ss, sf, or fs will be the worst case and why. Worst case circuit analysis wcca is a set of techniques used to analyze how variations in parameters influence circuit performance. However, you can understand worst case design by using basic circuit equations and the components limit values to calculate the range of worst case values that a circuit parameter, such as output voltage, can assume over the life of the equipment. An approach of the worst case analysis of the analog electronic circuits based on the circuit description in parameter space is proposed. Basic circuit analysis 23 example the bridge circuit again we know that the seriesparallel reduction method is not useful for this circuit. Pdf an approach to worstcase circuit analysis semantic scholar. Introduction to worst case circuit analysis course overview.
Details of circuit design and worst case analysis are presented for two simple circuits. A method to create a worst case scenario and to detect the worst case minmax values of the outputs and performance attributes of the analog circuits is proposed in this paper. A worstcase analysis is a quantitative assessment of a circuit or systems functional performance, accounting for manufacturing, environmental. Jun 04, 2018 this first post in the worst case blog focuses on the skills, resources, and techniques needed to properly perform a worst case circuit analysis and some of the reasons why worst case circuit analysis wcca is challenging to get right.
In this paper, the authors intend to show how to apply the circuit description in parameter space for a standard worstcase circuit analysis wcca. Worst case circuit analysis an overview e e c t r n i p sc. A worstcase analysis is a quantitative assessment of a circuit or systems functional performance, accounting for manufacturing, environmental, aging, and, in the case of space applications, radiation tolerances. Pdf an approach to worstcase circuit analysis elena. Today, the availability of highspeed digital computers and circuit analysis pro grams has eased the task of performing an accurate worst case analysis of circuits. Worst case circuit analysis by pedro vitoriano wcca worst case circuit analysis nominal values tolerance variation due aging v1 5 v1tol 2% v1ag. Circuit under analysis process and application data prior product information. We have seen many methods of calculating the worst case tolerance limits for electronic circuits. Configuring a worst case analysis in multisim national.
Worst case circuit analysis can be considered as a step in the softfault diagnosis allowing us to find out the bound outputs or performance attributes of a circuit. This paper describes an approach adopted for a worst case circuit analysis done on an autonomous, passive, fail proof balancing electronic circuit used for cell balancing of lithium ion batteries. Introduction electronic circuit design starts with the customer electrical specifications. Average performance and worst case performance are the most used in algorithm analysis. This intensive course focuses on the fundamental skills required to perform a worst case circuit analysis wcca. Step by step guide for worst case analysis sensitivity analysis in pspice.
Combined parametric and worstcase circuit analysis via. The most revealing method is a worst case circuit stress analysis wccsa, which determines the stress levels on each component when variable parameters are at values that maximize stress on the component being analysed 1, 2. The question is how to apply the transformation so that the circuit can become solvable using the seriesparallel reduction or other ac. Worst case design analysis allows each component to be at its minimum or maximum value and then, based on the interaction of the individual components, computes the minimum and maximum expected performance values. Sandler is responsible for the design, worst case analysis. Approach uses a combination of worst case analysis and laser tests if hi data not available for specific application worst case analysis based on maximum amplitude and pulse width of set observed for different categories of part types rail to rail voltage amplitude 10 ms max pw for comparators 20 ms max pw for op amps. However, for a worst case analysis we would prefer not to use a distribution approach, instead the maximum deviation from the nominal value of each component are used in.
Worst case analysis is a statistical technique that uses a what if approach to provide a practical result and its primary purpose is to identify the most critical components of a circuit. Root sum of squares analysis uses the square root of the sum of the individual component tolerances squared. For example, the gain error introduced by nonideal resistors. Pdf wcca worst case circuit analysis pedro vitoriano. Worstcase analysis and optimization of vlsi circuit performances article pdf available in ieee transactions on computeraided design of integrated circuits and systems 144. Improve logic timing with worstcase analysis electronic design. Meeting specifications includes operating in the complete range of specified environmental conditions, including ambient temperature, shock, vibration, salt spray, humidity, and more. Variable process conditions may result in a case where the nmos and pmos devices have modi. Introduction the capability of accounting for the effects of stochastic andor parametric variations of design parameters on circuit. Edn why worstcase circuit analysis is challenging to. Worst case circuit analysis wcca is a costeffective means of screening a design to verify with a high degree of confidence that potential defects. It may be less expensive to discard a rare failure than to design for 100% yield.
Introduction to worst case circuit analysis for the aerospace. Initially a sensitivity analysis is run on each individual component which has a tolerance assigned. Preliminary analysis prior to performing a stress derating analysis, a thermal analysis and circuit analysis must first be completed. Circuit analysis with tolerances worst case analysis parameters are manipulated to produce the worst case min and max values of desired quantities. The intent of this paper is to demonstrate several different methods, and determine the results, and the corresponding confidence factors for each method. In this role it is a good backup to worst case analysis. Worstcase circuit analysis with minimal simulations runs. Aug 10, 2012 this continues the worse case analysis from the mathcad video but using pspice. Approaches to the detailed worst case circuit analysis, and an awareness on the need of the analysis to be performed before. This can lead to overdesign since the worst case combination of parameters is rare.
Combinational logic gates in cmos purdue engineering. Worst case circuit analysis an overview electronic parts circuits tolerance analysis abstract. Simple voltage divider worse case analysis using pspice youtube. Pdf worst case circuit analysis of a new balancing circuit for. Worst case analysis, electronic parts circuit tolerance analysis, worst case scenario, worst case part. Worst case circuit analysisan overview electronic parts. A comparison of tolerance analysis methods by steven m. Extreme value analysis eva eva involves evaluating a circuit s performance using every possible combination of extreme component value. These are worst case single and three phase bolted. Worst case circuit analysis wcca worst case circuit analysis wcca is a technique which, by accounting for component variability, determines circuit performance under a worst case scenario, i. Worstcase analysis worstcase circuit analysis is an analysis technique which, by accounting for component variability, determines the circuit performance under a worstcase scenario. Worstcase analysis is much more common than averagecase analysis because its often easier to get meaningful average case results, a reasonable probability model for typical inputs is critical, but may be unavailable, or dif. These analysis only use fictitious toleranceing and do not consider temperature, aging, and radiation drift. Worst case analysis or testing is most useful when you have a few parameters that are known to be troublesome, and when you can expect that the system will be at its worst when these parameters are at one end or another of their anticipated range.
Sandler has over 30 years experience in the design and analysis of power conversion equipment for military and space applications. Worst case circuit analysis application guidelines. Many algorithms with bad worst case performance have good average case performance. One approach is monte carlo analysis, in which parameters are randomly selected from a distribution, and the circuit simulated, anywhere from to 00 times. Circuit analysis is considered outside the scope of this document.
In brief, circuit analysis is the process used to calculate. Pdf worst case circuit analysis of a new balancing. Worst case circuit analysis an overview e e c t r n i p s. Worst case circuit analysis with monte carlo simulation. The worst case analysis lets us explore the worst possible effects of variations in component parameters on the performance of a circuit. An78method for calculating output voltage tolerances in. Pded1212 page 3 of 4 design and analysis of electronic circuits for worst case environments and part variations c rootsumsquare defined by the biases and standard deviations of the parts variability and magnitude. Traditional worst case analysis methods, although valid, result in unrealistic and excessively conservative estimates of the total tolerances leading to unnecessary added circuit costs.
Design for reliability techniques worst case circuit stress. Worst case circuit analysis is a method for determining circuit performance under extreme worst case conditions. Pdf worst case circuit analysis of a new balancing circuit. Worst case analysis is used to identify the most critical components which will affect circuit performance. Worst case analysis, electronic partscircuit tolerance analysis,worst case scenario, worst case part. In realtime computing, the worst case execution time is often of particular concern since it is important to know how much time might be needed in the worst case to guarantee that the algorithm will always finish on time. Analysis and design of digital integrated circuits. For the worst case, r k for both pullup and pulldown and the tplh and tphl are both equal to 0. Eva sensitivity analysis the parameter sensitivities are computed by evaluating the derivative of the output with respect to each component. This intensive course focuses on the fundamental skills required to. Extreme value analysis eva eva involves evaluating a circuits performance using every possible combination of extreme component value. Worst case circuit analysis with minimal simulations runs.
Worst case design lets the components assume a wide range. Upon showing the students a sample wcca we had produced for automotive module, there was audible mumbling. Aug 19, 2016 worst case analysis worst case circuit analysis is an analysis technique which, by accounting for component variability, determines the circuit performance under a worst case scenario. This document presents an overview of worst case circuit analysis. Reduced voltages for modern microprocessors are further increasing the demands on available voltage tolerances. An approach to worstcase circuit analysis semantic scholar. Worst case circuit analysis application guidelines concurrent engineering series. Why worstcase circuit analysis is challenging to perform edn.
From the design analysis handbook by ed walker worst case analysis wca is the mathematical determination of the limits of possible performance of a system to ensure that the desired system responses will not exceed specification limits and that. Index terms circuit simulation, interval analysis, parameterized modeling, parametric simulation, taylor models, tolerance analysis, uncertainty, worst case analysis. Ct saturation in industrial applications analysis and application guidelines. Introduction to worst case circuit analysis for the. Wcca analysis methods and techniques are fully explored. The stardelta transformation may solve this problem. The behaviour of an electronic circuit is affected when certain parameters in specific components change. Changes made to the baseline dmsp design are relatively minor and do not adversely effect the worst case analysis of the trmmesa electrical design. Teaming a formalized worst case design procedure with computer circuit analysis pro grams such as ecap ref. Pdf worstcase analysis and optimization of vlsi circuit. Worstcase design of op amp circuits introduction building reliable hardware requires all component tolerances to be accounted for during the design stage. Worst case circuit analysis wcca is a costeffective means of screening a design to verify with a high degree of confidence that potential defects and deficiencies are identified and eliminated. Examine the worst case to guarantee that the dynamic discipline is. This amortized worst case cost can be much closer to the average case cost, while still providing a guaranteed upper limit on the running time.
It is necessary that the proper impedance be used to represent the primary system. The results of this analysis and any associated circuit modifications are an important element in the initial development process. Dennis fitzpatrick, in analog design and simulation using orcad capture and pspice second edition, 2018. What will be the worst possible effects of variations in component parameters. Part parameter variation is the result of both internal and external factors. Worstcase circuit analysis wcca or wca is a costeffective means of screening a design to ensure with a high degree of confidence that potential defects and. Figure 1 worst case circuit stress analysis process flow, adapted from 2, 3. Shortcircuit current calculations singlephase short circuits short circuit calculations on a singlephase center tapped transformer system require a slightly different procedure than 3o faults on 3o systems. Worst case circuit analysis application guidelines concurrent engineering series johanson, brian on. The worst case analysis is related to the worst case complexity. For our example, we had drawn a group of resistors powered by 12vdc supply. The trmmesa design is a proven heritage design and capable of withstanding the most worst case and adverse of circuit conditions. I asked, what was the matter and one student exclaimed, we dont have time for that.
742 929 1291 1251 351 8 897 819 481 973 726 407 886 457 14 1375 228 319 331 241 998 1229 420 35 1309 407 521 453 743 1323 1275 1163 768 1419 349 635 192 391 764 647 698 521 1415 895 289 514 1025 168 983